About us

Original Italian Pizza is a renowned pizza restaurant located in Sayre, PA. With a passion for delivering authentic Italian flavors, we take pride in offering our customers a delightful dining experience.

Our team of skilled chefs meticulously crafts each pizza using only the finest ingredients, ensuring every bite is bursting with flavor. From classic favorites to unique specialty pizzas, our menu has something to satisfy every palate. Whether you dine in, take out, or have it delivered, we strive to provide exceptional service and mouthwatering pizzas that will keep you coming back for more.

Our Reputation and Quality says it all.  By choosing the best ingredients and our committed effort, we have created the best pizza in town. 
Thank You,

The Amato Family

Our History
Original Italian Pizza was opened in 1972 and has been providing high quality food to our community ever since. Original Italian Pizza is a family owned restaurant. Our mission is to provide the local community with exceptional quality food at a fair price. We take pride in serving our community the best pizza and Italian cuisine in the valley.
 

Pizza better than "the Hut" for sure. They even have a great selection of gourmet pizza by the slice as well. Stopped by yesterday, 28Apr, and had eggplant parm. Parm was good, pasta was not drained well and sauce was WAY watered down. Waitress made it right and meal was finished.

Read more
Lawrence Dusek (Larry)

Lawrence Dusek (Larry)

2 days ago

Robert Waltman

Robert Waltman

3 days ago

Absolutely love the food here!! My favorite dish is the tortellini Alfredo!!! So good always delivered super hot and super quick the employees are great as well very nice!!

Read more
Jamie Richtmyer

Jamie Richtmyer

a week ago

Vicky Kumar

Vicky Kumar

a week ago

Great subs and pizza. Their cheesesteak and eggplant parm sandwiches are also super good, and the service is pretty fast.

Read more
Desh Cooper

Desh Cooper

a week ago

Carol Worden

Carol Worden

2 weeks ago